When it comes to coin collecting, it’s often the coins in mint condition that fetch the highest prices. But believe it or not, there are a handful of quarters floating around in everyday change that are worth significantly more than 25 cents—even if they’ve been well-used.
Let’s dive into some of the most valuable quarters still in circulation, how to spot them, and what makes them so appealing to collectors.
1. 2019-W and 2020-W West Point Quarters
In a surprising move, the U.S. Mint released a limited number of quarters from the West Point Mint in 2019 and 2020. These coins are special because, unlike other collector coins, they were actually released into everyday circulation—just 2 million of each design per year.
What makes them stand out? The small “W” mintmark under “IN GOD WE TRUST” on the obverse. That’s your clue.
Even though they’re relatively new, their low mintage and limited run make them potential collector favorites in the future. If you find one, it’s definitely worth holding on to—it could be a sleeper hit in the numismatic world.
2. 1932-D Washington Quarter
The 1932-D quarter marks the beginning of the Washington quarter series. Struck in Denver, only 436,800 were minted—an incredibly small number for any U.S. coin.
Look for the “D” mintmark on the reverse, just above the “ER” in “QUARTER.” Even in rough condition, these coins are worth much more than face value. A heavily worn one graded just “1” by PCGS can still be valued at $225.
If it’s in better shape, say around “About Uncirculated” (AU55), it could be worth upwards of $525. Rare even in low grades, the 1932-D is a bucket-list find for collectors.
3. 1932-S Washington Quarter
The 1932-S is another gem from the first year of the Washington series. With a slightly lower mintage than its Denver counterpart—just 408,000 coins—it’s even scarcer.
Today, it’s estimated that only around 40,000 have survived. The “S” mintmark is found in the same place as the Denver version.
Values range from $85 for a coin graded 2, to over $360 for one nearing mint state (AU58+). If you stumble across one, it’s definitely worth getting appraised—even PCGS’s $40 grading fee might be worth the investment.
4. 1937-S Washington Quarter
While not as rare as the 1932 versions, the 1937-S quarter still commands attention thanks to its relatively low mintage for the era.
Prices are more modest, but still significant. A coin graded as low as “3” is worth about $8, and one in “Extremely Fine” condition (EF45) can fetch around $100. If yours is close to uncirculated, its value could rise to $165 or more.
5. 2004-D Wisconsin State Quarter – Extra Leaf (Low Variety)
The 50 State Quarters program brought us some stunning designs, but the 2004-D Wisconsin quarter includes one of the most intriguing modern errors.
Some coins feature an extra leaf near the corn husk on the reverse—likely the result of a die gouge or possibly even an intentional addition. The “Low Leaf” version shows the added leaf pointing downward, touching the cheese wheel.
Though over 227 million Wisconsin quarters were made in Denver, only a fraction bear this error. A coin graded VF30 could be worth about $38, and that jumps to $80 at grade 55. A fun find with a quirky backstory!
6. 2004-D Wisconsin State Quarter – Extra Leaf (High Variety)
The rarer sibling of the “Low Leaf” is the “High Leaf” error. Here, the extra leaf juts upward and partially hides behind the regular corn husk design.
Because it’s tougher to find, values are slightly higher. A VF30 example might bring in $45, while one in better condition (VF45 or higher) could be worth $75 or more.
These small differences in design make a big impact when it comes to collectability—and value.
Final Thoughts: Hidden Treasures in Your Pocket Change
You don’t need to be a seasoned numismatist to find valuable coins. Some of the most prized quarters in circulation today were released with little fanfare or hidden surprises. Whether it’s a rare mintmark, a historical first-year issue, or an unexpected die error, these coins prove that treasures can turn up anywhere—even in your spare change.
If you think you’ve found something special, it’s worth doing a bit of research or getting a professional appraisal. Who knows? That humble quarter might just be your next big discovery.
FAQs
How can I tell if my quarter is from the West Point Mint?
Look for a small “W” mintmark on the obverse side of the coin, just below “IN GOD WE TRUST.”
Are circulated rare quarters still valuable?
Yes, even well-worn rare quarters like the 1932-D or 1932-S can be worth hundreds of dollars depending on their condition.
What is the difference between the Extra Leaf High and Low Wisconsin quarters?
The Extra Leaf Low points downward toward the cheese wheel, while the Extra Leaf High points upward and partially hides behind the corn husk.
Should I get my rare quarter professionally graded?
If your coin appears to be in good condition and is a known rare variety, grading can increase its value to collectors, though it typically costs around $40.
I have collectedable coins that i want graded to sell, where do i send them, phone number and address…thank u
EDITH IF YOU WANT TOP TIER GRADING BY THE MOST PRESTIGIOUS GRADING COMPANY ON PLANET EARTH THEN YOU WILL WANT THE COMPANY CALLED (P.C.G.S.) THEY ALSO HAVE A WEBSITE YOU CAN VISIT, ALSO I DO BELIEVE THEY HAVE A BOOK CALLED THE BIG RED BOOK. side note if you are yo send it in to a coin grading company just know that grading can be expensive but Having a P.C.G.S. Graded Coin is as good as it gets but if they are to spendy and you just want to know if your coin is legitimate or not my suggestion would be to look up in your county or in your state try and find a Coin Show that’s happening at a Convention Center you walk into a coin show and you go up to that one of the booths of the experts there they can grade it right there on the spot and 9 times out of 10 they’ll do it for free. 🙂
I have several wheat pennies ranging from 1941to 1943 the magnetic one, 2 bicentennial quarters that’s on the page of valuable quarters. Reasonable offer can get them. James Bell 225-220-9992, [email protected]. Can be reached 24/7
Sorry to say , but none of those are worth much more than face value. Even the steel ones.
So far I have three most valuable dollar quarters for following years counsin state quarter of 2004,Washington drummer boy quarter dollar of 1776-1976 then2005 quarter dollar.
I have coin in lagos Nigeria
I have the United Arab Emirates